Provenance Dossier
A chased silver presentation plate of Egyptian origin, accepted as a diplomatic gift by a senior CIA official circa 2015. Supported by Federal Register and GSA records, the piece represents a rare surviving example of modern U.S. intelligence-related state gift silver.
*** NOTE: This item is now live on eBay. ***



Object Summary
- Chased silver presentation plate depicting three Egyptian female musicians beneath a stylized sunburst.
- Includes original blue velvet presentation case with fitted interior and lacquered wooden display stand.
- Material: .900 silver (Arabic hallmark “٩٠٠” to verso).
- Hallmarks: Two-compartment punch — left: “٩٠٠”; right: distinctive emblem consistent with non-commercial diplomatic workshop practice.
- Dimensions / Weight: 10.5 in diameter · 265 g (8.5 troy oz).
- Date: c. 2015–2017 (based on hallmark style and confirmed federal custody dates).
- Origin: Cairo, Arab Republic of Egypt.
- Overall Condition: Excellent
- Surface: very minor scuffs consistent with handling
- Label: Government intake sticker “15-028” intact on verso
Provenance & Chain of Custody (Documented)
FOREIGN GIFTS reported to GSA on SF120 forms 2017-2021:
- Referenced in GSA correspondence responding to a 2021 FOIA request confirming GSA turn-in and excess dates
| ICN | Reporting Agency | Description | Value | FY | Recipient | Donor Agency | Donor Name | Turned in to GSA | Surplus Date |
| 56310182000013 | US Gov’t Agency | PLATE, EGYPTIAN CHASED SILVER PICTORIAL , DEPICTING THREE FEMALE MUSICIANS. | $500 | 2018 | US Gov’t Agency | US Gov’t Agency | Foreign Donor | 08/22/2018 | 07/19/2018 |
GSA Foreign Gifts Program Database:
- Referenced in GSA correspondence responding to a second 2021 FOIA request confirming CIA custody
| ICN | Agency | Name | Est Cost | Recipient | Donor | Description | Reported | Reported Excess |
| 56310182000013 | CIA | bc PLATE SILVER PICTORIAL | $500 | CIA Officer | Foreign Donor | PLATE, EGYPTIAN CHASED SILVER PICTORIAL , DEPICTING THREE FEMALE MUSICIANS. | 7/19/2018 | 08/22/18 |
Public Sale (GSA Auctions):
- Listing: GSA Auctions (Springfield, VA) with language that mirrors SF-120 and Foreign Gift Program Database.
- Buyer: Present owner (consignor).
- Receipt: GSA Auction Screenshot shows ICN 56310182000013. Purchase receipt confirms acquisition via public auction.
Provenance line (catalog-ready):
Foreign Diplomatic Gift from the Government of Egypt; accepted by a CIA officer under 5 U.S.C. §7342; held in U.S. government custody under ICN 56310182000013 with original intake label “15-028” preserved; declared surplus 22 August 2018 and disposed of via GSA Auctions, Springfield, VA; acquired by the present owner.
Hallmark Analysis (Summary)
- Format: Rectangular two-compartment punch.
- Left compartment: Arabic numerals “٩٠٠” = .900 silver fineness (90% purity), standard for Egyptian presentation silver.
- Right compartment: A distinctive Egyptian emblem. Its form—tall, glyph-like; resembles Winged Goddess Isis.
- Interpretation: Most Egyptian silver from this era bears three marks (purity + national + date). This two-compartment variation is less commonly seen, and may reflect a special-purpose or institutional production, though its exact origin remains under study.
- Conclusion: Hallmarks corroborate Egyptian origin and official commission; together with the federal records, they strongly support the piece’s diplomatic status.
Diplomatic Context (by process of elimination)
This artifact was cross-referenced against official U.S. government records of foreign gifts reported under 5 U.S.C. § 7342, which mandates disclosure of gifts received by federal officials above the “minimal value” threshold. The Federal Register listings for the Central Intelligence Agency were carefully examined for corresponding entries that match the description of this chased silver plate and other known metadata. This analysis produced one unique record fully consistent with the artifact’s known characteristics:
Federal Register 70516 / Vol. 81, No. 197 / Wednesday, October 12, 2016
“Silver plate. Rec’d—6/30/2015. Est. Value—$500.00. Disposition—Pending transfer to General Services Administration.”
Recipient: The Honorable John O. Brennan, Director of the Central Intelligence Agency
This entry represents the only occurrence in the Federal Register meeting all required criteria:
- CIA provenance
- Silver material composition
- Stated diplomatic gift
- Assigned valuation of $500
- Documented transfer to GSA
- Receipt date prior to the GSA disposition record for this artifact
Taken together, the statutory reporting, agency-specific Federal Register citation, value designation, and transfer chain collectively support the conclusion that the silver item addressed in this dossier is the same “silver plate” presented to then-CIA Director John O. Brennan on June 30, 2015, in the course of official diplomatic engagement. The surviving government intake label of 15-028 also supports this conclusion, as it is a strong indicator of a 2015 diplomatic exchange.
Most probable event:
On 19 April 2015, CIA Director John O. Brennan made an unannounced visit to Cairo, where he held discussions with Abdel Fattah el‑Sisi, President of the Arab Republic of Egypt. According to an Egyptian presidential statement, the talks focused on enhancing bilateral cooperation of mutual strategic interest — particularly in the domains of counter-terrorism and regional security. Egypt’s official press further confirms that “the duo met in Cairo last April” in the context of expanding the U.S.–Egypt partnership.
Given the publicly reported timing and location of Director Brennan’s trip — and the contemporaneous value, reference and custody chain of the artifact (a silver plate valued at $500, received by the CIA on 30 June 2015) — this diplomatic event emerges as the most probable context for the gift’s presentation. The April 2015 meeting aligns closely with the June acceptance date recorded in the Federal Register, and corresponds to the high-level engagement milieu in which a gift to the Director of the CIA would reasonably be bestowed.
In other words: the silver plate appears likely to have been conferred during Brennan’s Cairo engagement days earlier, as part of a diplomatic gesture linked to the U.S.–Egypt intelligence and security partnership under the Sisi administration. While the absence of an explicit public announcement tying the plate to the meeting prevents absolute certainty, the alignment of timing, recipient, agency, and value make this event by far the most plausible origin of the item.
Additional Context
Interestingly, within the same approximate diplomatic timeframe, a very similar silver presentation plate was recorded in public U.S. foreign-gift disclosures under the presidency of Barack Obama. That plate is described as a “circular tray depicting three Egyptian women playing musical instruments under the sun. Rec’d — 2/12/2016. Est. Value — $550.00. Disposition — National Archives and Records Administration. Donor: His Excellency Abdel Fattah el‑Sisi, President of the Arab Republic of Egypt.” (Federal Register, Jan 11 2018). Though not identical in every descriptive detail, the form (a silver-plate diplomatic gift from Egypt with similar motif), material (silver), donor (Egyptian head of state) and timing (2016) closely parallel the object under review. This circumstance does not in itself confirm full identity, but it strongly reinforces the plausibility of our attribution: the same foreign-government gifting practice appears within the same bilateral diplomatic channel, supporting the conclusion that the plate accepted by the CIA in 2015 was part of sustained Egyptian diplomatic silver gifting practice.
Summary
This plate represents a rare example of modern diplomatic silver with clear, verifiable CIA provenance. It would make an excellent display piece for collectors of intelligence history, diplomatic memorabilia, or international presentation silver.
Because the U.S. Government does not individually photograph or serialize diplomatic gifts in the Federal Register, objects are identified by descriptive attributes rather than unique personal inscriptions. In this case, those attributes—supported by the Federal Register record, GSA FOIA correspondence, SF-120 documentation, and matching intake tag and valuation—converge uniquely on the silver plate reported as received by Director Brennan. While no physical inscription names him directly, the documented chain of custody and characteristic profile establish a high-confidence attribution to the diplomatic gift presented during his tenure as Director of the CIA.















